Insurance
How ERGO NEXT Insurance Is Scaling Legal Through an Acquisition

Nadia Louis-Hermez
Head of Legal Operations at ERGO NEXT Insurance
Customer story
ERGO NEXT Insurance is a digital-first commercial insurance provider for small businesses, based in Palo Alto, California. Licensed in all 50 states and covering more than 600 business classes, the company serves over 850,000 customers and is targeting $1.15 billion in written premiums for 2026, providing coverage both directly and in partnership with other insurance companies and agencies. Behind that growth sits a 14-person legal team that supports around 700 employees worldwide, with half of its members dedicated to compliance, laws, and regulations.


Legal
DEPARTMENT
700
COMPANY size
14
LEGAL TEAM size
The Challenge
The challenge
An acquisition multiplied legal's workload by 3 to 4x, and the team had no single place to capture, route, or measure the requests coming in.
Nadia Louis-Hermez joined ERGO NEXT about five years ago to implement the company's contract lifecycle management (CLM) tool, and once it was up and running, contracts had a home. The rest of legal's work, however, was a different story. As an insurance company, ERGO NEXT's legal team fields requests across corporate governance, compliance, risk, new laws and regulations, litigation, marketing, and even claims, while the CLM only tracked one lane of that work.
Most of those other requests landed in a shared legal inbox that caught "everything under the sun," from service of process to claim emails sent by insureds. The company also had an internal wiki that served as a knowledge source, but with so much content to read through, nobody in the business had time to dig for answers there.
Nadia had been advocating for a legal front door for three years, and while her General Counsel fully supported the idea, budget remained the sticking point. Because legal is often seen as a cost center, the team was asked to use a ticketing system the company already owned. Nadia gave it a fair try, but it soon ran into three problems:
- It added friction for the business. Every request meant filling out another form, and sometimes a lengthy one.
- Legal couldn't change it on their own. Updating the wording on a ticket, or adjusting its conditions and triggers, meant raising a separate ticket and waiting on someone else to make the change.
- It lacked AI. There was very little automation, so the legal team still had to handle the triage work.
Then, in 2025, NEXT Insurance was fully acquired by Munich Re's ERGO Group and rebranded as ERGO NEXT Insurance. Six months on, the legal team was still 14 people, but the volume of incoming work had grown by 3 to 4x. On top of running the business, the team now had to answer requests and projects from the new parent company, including at least 60 new norms and policies that needed to be implemented across ERGO NEXT. So at the start of 2026, Nadia and her GC sat down to figure out how they would get their arms around it all.
“In this day and age, people expect legal to act fast. So if I needed to make a change to the ticket, I shouldn't have to rely on somebody else to do it for me.”
The Solution
The solution
ERGO NEXT chose Checkbox for its agentic AI and its ability to keep pace with a changing business, then launched an AI agent called Ask Vinny in small, deliberate phases.
ERGO NEXT ran a formal RFP over a couple of weeks, and the evaluation came down to Checkbox and one other vendor. Throughout the process, Nadia had her GC in her corner, which she credits as a key factor in getting the project over the line.
Above all, the team wanted sophisticated agentic AI, since a business in the middle of a post-acquisition transition needed a platform that could keep up with it. ERGO NEXT's CEO is also a strong proponent of AI, so the legal front door doubled as a way to show the rest of the organization that legal was leading on AI rather than trailing behind. In the end, Checkbox stood out for both its ability to adapt as the business changed and the strength of its AI.
Why Checkbox?
- Sophisticated agentic AI that could handle high-volume, low-touch requests on legal's behalf.
- Keeps pace with change, so the platform could evolve alongside a business in the middle of an acquisition.
- Meets the business where it works, with requests coming in through Slack, direct messages, and email instead of yet another form.
- Controlled, closed environment that supports privilege, with access managed through single sign-on and permissions set dashboard by dashboard.
Mapping the work before building it
The day after signing with Checkbox, Nadia started on a planning document. She sat down with members of the legal team, including the records custodian who handles subpoenas, litigation, and discovery requests, as well as the marketing attorney, and asked each of them to write out their processes. Together, they decided which marketing requests needed legal review and which could go straight through the AI agent, then split the rollout into two phases.
Phase 1: High-volume, low-touch requests
Phase 1 covers ERGO NEXT's norms and policies, contracts that connect to its CLM, and the general requests that arrive through Slack, direct messages, and email, all of which now go through the team's AI agent.
Phase 2: Bigger, substantive work
Once Phase 1 is in place, Phase 2 will take on the bigger, more substantive processes that affect a wider group of people across the organization.
Ask Vinny
Vinny answers from the knowledge source the legal team provides, under ground rules legal set: no assumptions, and a standing reminder that it is not an attorney. When a question needs more than that guidance can answer with confidence, Vinny opens a request and routes it to a human on the legal team.
Every request also gets sorted on the way in. Vinny identifies whether it relates to a norm or policy, corporate governance, or laws and regulations, so it lands in the right place. It also records which channel the request came through. When the California Department of Insurance emailed Nadia about a new law, she forwarded it to Vinny, which filed it to the right matter. Before Checkbox, that email would have landed in the shared legal inbox with everything else.
Transparency and privilege were built in from the start. Every response from Vinny opens by telling the user that it is an AI agent, not a human, and not a lawyer, and each conversation is a closed, one-to-one interaction visible only to the requester and the reviewing attorney. Access requires an ERGO NEXT login through single sign-on, and because permissions can be set for each dashboard, sensitive areas like corporate governance stay limited to the right people.
“Vinny will answer the question as much as possible, and if it stops, it will create a ticket and route it to a human. So at the end of the day, though, the human will always be in the loop if Vinny gives up and cannot answer the question.”

Customer perspective
“We were impressed by the fact that it can keep up with the business as it changed, and we didn't feel like the other tools could do that for us. The AI component was incredibly impressive for us.”
3 to 4x
Increase in legal request volume after the acquisition, with the same 14-person team now routing high-volume, low-touch requests through Ask Vinny.
60+
New post-acquisition norms and policies brought into Phase 1, so employees can get answers from Ask Vinny instead of waiting on legal.
1 front door
Requests from Slack, direct messages, and email now flow through a single AI agent, with every ticket recording where it came from.
Outcomes
The outcomes
Ask Vinny is already filtering high-volume, low-touch requests away from lawyers, and every request now feeds the data legal needs to prove its value.
ERGO NEXT is still building out its Checkbox tools and has not yet released Ask Vinny to the wider organization, but so far, Nadia says it is behaving the way she wants it to. Vinny acts as a filtration system, answering routine questions from the knowledge source legal controls and sending everything that needs legal input straight to the right person on the legal team.
That filtration matters for more than workload. Before Checkbox, legal's metrics came from its CLM, which tracks contract volume and turnaround times but covers only one lane of what the team does. Now, every request that passes through Ask Vinny will capture what type of request it is, its category, who asked, and which department it came from. In other words, legal will have a view of its work across every lane, not just contracts.
With that data in hand, the team plans to run metrics and build reports at the end of the year so the GC can show the CEO and CFO exactly what legal has accomplished.
| Outcome | Detail |
|---|---|
| One front door | Requests from Slack, direct messages, and email flow through Ask Vinny instead of scattering across inboxes. |
| Controlled AI | Vinny answers only from the knowledge source legal provides, and escalates anything it cannot answer with full confidence. |
| Human in the loop | Escalated requests become tickets, automatically routed to legal ops or the right member of the legal team. |
| Transparency for requesters | Every response tells the user they are talking to a bot, not a human or a lawyer. |
| Privilege protected | Conversations are one-to-one, access runs through single sign-on, and permissions are set dashboard by dashboard. |
| Visibility into every request | Each ticket records its source, and request data spans every lane of legal work, not only contracts. |
| Foundation for ROI | Request types, categories, requesters, and departments will be tracked for year-end reporting to the CEO and CFO. |
“How are you going to manage ROI if you don't have good data? And where is this data being fed from? Now that we have Ask Vinny, this data is going to be managed by Vinny.”
The Future
What’s next
As Phase 1 takes shape, ERGO NEXT is preparing to open Ask Vinny to the wider business and move on to bigger, more substantive processes.
Nadia is deliberately rolling Checkbox out in small pieces, because each early win builds confidence across the organization and makes it easier to take on the next, larger project. Once Ask Vinny is released to the rest of the business, the team will move on to Phase 2 of its planning document and the substantive processes that touch more people across ERGO NEXT.
Meanwhile, the request data flowing through Vinny is building toward year-end reporting, giving the GC a way to show the CEO and CFO the full scope of legal's work, well beyond contract volume and turnaround times.
“Do the small wins, because that's how you're going to recruit the change management piece. When people start seeing the small wins, that's when you can go on to the bigger projects, to the bigger processes.”
What does this mean for your legal team?
- Give existing tools a fair try. If IT wants you to repurpose a tool the company already owns, give it a go, so that if it falls short, you will have clear reasons why when you make the case for something better.
- Find your executive sponsor. Nadia's GC shared her vision for a legal front door, and that backing made the difference.
- Map processes with the people who own them. Sit down with each member of your legal team, have them write out their process, and decide which requests need legal review at all.
- Start small and win early. Begin with high-volume, low-touch requests, show people the outputs, and use that momentum for the bigger projects.
- Keep your AI controlled and transparent. Tell your agent not to make assumptions, have it identify itself as a bot, and make sure it hands off to a human when it cannot answer.
- Build for the data you will need. You cannot prove ROI without good data, so make sure every request is captured, categorized, and reportable.
- Get IT involved as early as possible. Implementation blockers that surface late can stall a project, so engage IT early while there is still time to address them.
- Build your business case with Finance in mind. Shape your ROI story so it lands with both Finance and legal leadership.
“Start out small. Do the easy wins. Get the high volume, low touch requests out of the way. Show people the outputs. Start tracking your data, your ROI from there, and then move on to the next one.”
Related Case Studies
Open a request, knowing it’s the right use of your time.
See how Checkbox handles the sorting on every incoming request, so your team spends its attention on the matters that earn it rather than on working out where things go.




















